Event Banner

UPDATE: In wake of appellate ruling against it, Western Michigan University grants student athletes religious exemptions to vaccine mandate

/

UPDATE: A month after the 6th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals ruled that Western Michigan University officials had unconstitutionally infringed on the religious liberty rights of student-athletes who had applied for religious exemptions to the school’s COVID vaccine mandate, the school has now granted those exemptions. The students will not be kicked off of their respective sports teams for failing to take the vaccine, but they do have to continue wearing a mask and must test weekly.

The original story on this court case can be read below.

The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled unanimously in favor of a group of student athletes at Western Michigan University (WMU) who were seeking a religious exemption from the schoolโ€™s COVID-19 vaccine mandate.

Quick Facts

The 16 athletes, who are mostly female, sought a vaccine exemption on religious grounds but were ignored or denied. They then filed a federal civil rights suit against the school. U.S. District Judge Paul Maloney initially ruled that the WMU vaccine requirement likely violates the athleteโ€™s constitutional rights to follow their Christian faith and ordered a 14-day temporary restraining order on the university’s shot mandate for athletes. The university appealed to the Sixth Circuit Appeals Court, but a three-judge panel with the Sixth Circuit Appeals Court declined to block the initial ruling.

โ€œWe do not doubt (WMUโ€™s) good faith, nor do we fail to appreciate the burdens COVID-19 has placed on this nationโ€™s universities,โ€ the court explained in a 3-0 opinion. โ€œBut having announced a system under which student athletes can seek individualized exemptions, the university must explain why it chose not to grant any to plaintiffs. And it did not fairly do so hereโ€ฆ. By conditioning the privilege of playing sports on plaintiffsโ€™ willingness to abandon their sincere religious beliefs, the University burdened their free exercise rights.โ€ 

The panel further contended that the athletes were likely to prevail on their constitutional argument if the university pursued an appeal.

WMU argued that its vaccination policy is neutral towards religion, and athletes who seek a religious exemption, while unable to compete, are still considered members of the team and can keep their scholarships. However, the appeals courts was not persuaded by the schoolโ€™s reasoning, stating, โ€œYet playing on the team, and not just receiving a scholarship, is their goal, a point the university itself recognized.โ€

The student athletes, who participate in intercollegiate soccer, basketball, and four other sports, said that they are โ€œdevoted Christian people,โ€ who believe that the Bible and their faith have guided their decisions to seek religious exemptions for the COVID-19 vaccine. The courtโ€™s ruling did allow WMU to require the unvaccinated student athletes to wear a mask at practice or submit to regular testing.

Mat Staver, founder and chairman of Liberty Counsel, which represented the students, hailed the ruling by saying, โ€œThis is a great victory for these athletes against these unlawful COVID shot mandates. Western Michigan University violates federal law when these school officials deny these studentsโ€™ religious exemptions. No school may force or coerce anyone to take these injections, and certainly not when doing so violates sincerely held religious beliefs.โ€ 

The decision is similar to a federal judgeโ€™s ruling that medical students at Edward Via College of Osteopathic Medicine (VCOM) must be granted the right to religious exemptions and allowed to see patients despite that exemption. Generally speaking, vaccine mandates at universities to this point are being upheld in court; however, the courts are also ruling that those mandates must grant religious exemptions to students under the Constitutionโ€™s clear protection of religious liberty. Unless these unvaccinated athletes are actually sick with COVID-19 and therefore contagious, there is no reason why they should not be allowed to play as fully active members of their teams.

Tired of your social media feed being censored?

For more timely, informative, and faith-based content, subscribe to the Standing for Freedom Center Newsletter

ร—
Join us in our mission to secure the foundations of freedom for future generations
Donate Now
Completing this poll entitles you to receive communications from Liberty University free of charge.ย  You may opt out at any time.ย  You also agree to our Privacy Policy.